Getty Images
東日本大震災の津波に耐えたが、その後枯れてしまった岩手県陸前高田市の「奇跡の一本松」の復元をやり直す作業が5月27日から始まったが、ネット上では疑問の声も出ている。
「奇跡の一本松」の復元作業は、今年３月に終了する予定だったが、「以前と姿が違う」という指摘を受けて、枝の取り付け部分の角度などを調整する。復元作業をやり直すことになった。陸前高田市は６月末には作業を終え、７月上旬に完成式典をする予定だ。産経新聞では次のように報じている。
一本松は景勝地、高田松原の約７万本の中で唯一残ったが、枯死。幹を防腐処理し、枝葉をレプリカで再現して復元する。市は復元に必要な費用約１億５千万円の寄付を募り、これまでに１億２５００万円以上が集まった。やり直し作業に伴う業者との契約額に変更はないという。
(MSN産経ニュース 2013/5/27 13:18)
今回の復元やり直しに対して、ネット上では「金の無駄遣い」「目的がずれている」など、さまざまな異論が噴出している。
さらに、そもそも「奇跡の一本松」を復元するという行為に対して批判的な声も多い。なかでもフリーライターの赤木智弘氏は、「どうして立ち枯れという現実を受け容れないのか」と、言葉を強めている。
（※読者の皆様は、「奇跡の一本松」復元事業についてどのように考えますか？コメント欄にご意見をお寄せください）
関連記事
奇跡の一本松
暗闇によみがえる一本松(01 of24)
東日本大震災で津波の被害を受けた岩手県陸前高田市で２８日、復元された「奇跡の一本松」がライトアップされた。７月３日に行われる完成式典前の試験点灯。東京スカイツリーと同じ技術を使ったＬＥＤ照明など９灯が、暗闇に立つ一本松を浮かび上がらせた。幹の下部は電球色で「追悼」、枝葉の部分は白色で「希望」を表している。同市では試験点灯で４パターンを試し、今後どう運用するか検討するという。７月３日から１年間行われる予定。 (credit:時事通信社)
東日本大震災・枝葉が切り取られた「奇跡の一本松」 (02 of24)
保存のための伐採作業で、枝葉が切り取られた「奇跡の一本松」＝１２日午前、岩手県陸前高田市\n\n2012年09月12日撮影 (credit:時事通信社)
「奇跡の一本松」(03 of24)
2013年3月10日、復元工事中の「奇跡の一本松」（岩手県陸前高田市） (credit:AFP時事)
東日本大震災・奇跡の一本松の先端部の修復作業(04 of24)
奇跡の一本松の先端部の修復作業＝２０１３年２月２５日午後、相模原市 (credit:時事通信社)
東日本大震災２年・組み立てられる「奇跡の一本松」の枝葉 (05 of24)
現地で行われる「奇跡の一本松」の枝葉の組み立て作業。復元作業で枝葉のレプリカが元の姿と違っていたことが分かり、作業のやり直しが決まった＝２０１３年３月２日、岩手県陸前高田市 \n (credit:時事通信社)
JAPAN-DISASTER-ANNIVERSARY-TSUNAMI(06 of24)
Residents look at a replica of a lone pine tree (C) after a memorial ceremony to commemorate the second anniversary of huge March 11 earthquake and tsunami disasters in Rikuzentakata on March 10, 2013. March 11, 2013 marks the second anniversary of the 9.0 magnitude earthquake that sent a huge wall of water into the coast of the Tohoku region, splintering whole communities, ruining swathes of prime farmland and killing nearly 19,000 people. The original pine which survived the 2011 tsunami and stood as a symbol of hope, was cut down in September, 2012, treated for decay, preserved and reburied only recently. AFP PHOTO / TOSHIFUMI KITAMURA (credit:AFP＝時事)
JAPAN-DISASTER-ANNIVERSARY-TSUNAMI (07 of24)
Residents walk towards a replica of a lone pine tree (R) after a memorial ceremony to commemorate the second anniversary of huge March 11 earthquake and tsunami disasters in Rikuzentakata on March 10, 2013. March 11, 2013 marks the second anniversary of the 9.0 magnitude earthquake that sent a huge wall of water into the coast of the Tohoku region, splintering whole communities, ruining swathes of prime farmland and killing nearly 19,000 people. The original pine which survived the 2011 tsunami and stood as a symbol of hope, was cut down in September, 2012, treated for decay, preserved and reburied only recently. AFP PHOTO / TOSHIFUMI KITAMURA (credit:AFP＝時事)
「奇跡の一本松」に枝葉設置 (08 of24)
枝葉の設置作業が進む「奇跡の一本松」＝６日午前、岩手県陸前高田市\n\n撮影日：2013年03月06日 (credit:時事通信社)
復活間近の「奇跡の一本松」 (09 of24)
復活に向けて設置作業が行われる「奇跡の一本松」の幹＝２日午前、岩手県陸前高田市 (credit:時事通信社)
東日本大震災・工事の一部やり直しが決まった一本松 (10 of24)
枝葉部分の施工ミスが判明し、工事の一部やり直しが決まった「奇跡の一本松」＝２０１３年３月６日、岩手県陸前高田市 (credit:時事通信社)
東日本大震災・一本松の先端部の修復作業(11 of24)
奇跡の一本松の先端部の修復作業＝２月２５日午後、相模原市 (credit:時事通信社)
Japan To Mark 2nd Anniversary Of Magnitude 9.0 Earthquake And Tsunami(12 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 10: Vistors walk in front of a replica of the pine tree prior to the second anniversary of the tsunami and earthquake on March 10, 2013 in Rikuzentakata, Iwate prefecture, Japan. On March 11 Japan will commemorate the second anniversary of the magnitude 9.0 earthquake and following tsunami that claimed more than 18,000 lives. (Photo by Ken Ishii/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Japan Prepares To Mark One Year Anniversary Of Earthquake And Tsunami(13 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 07: A single pine tree that was left standing after the March 11th tsunami, which swept away an entire forest in the city of Rikuzentakata, is seen on March 07, 2012 in Rikuzentakata, Japan. People see the tree\'s miraculous survival as a symbol of hope and want to preserve it as a living monument. As the one year anniversary approaches, the areas most affected by an earthquake and subsequent tsunami, that left 15,848 dead and 3,305 missing according to Japan\'s National Police Agency, continue to struggle. Thousands of people still remain without homes living in temporary dwellings. The Japanese government faces an uphill battle with the need to dispose of rubble as it works to rebuild economies and livelihoods. (Photo by Daniel Berehulak/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Japan Prepares To Mark One Year Anniversary Of Earthquake And Tsunami(14 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 07: A single pine tree that was left standing after the March 11th tsunami, which swept away an entire forest in the city of Rikuzentakata, is seen on March 07, 2012 in Rikuzentakata, Japan. People see the tree\'s miraculous survival as a symbol of hope and want to preserve it as a living monument. As the one year anniversary approaches, the areas most affected by an earthquake and subsequent tsunami, that left 15,848 dead and 3,305 missing according to Japan\'s National Police Agency, continue to struggle. Thousands of people still remain without homes living in temporary dwellings. The Japanese government faces an uphill battle with the need to dispose of rubble as it works to rebuild economies and livelihoods. (Photo by Daniel Berehulak/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Japan Prepares To Mark 1 Year Anniversary Of Earthquake And Tsunami(15 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 09: A single pine tree is left standing after last year\'s March 11th tsunami, which swept away an entire forest in the city of Rikuzentakata, on March 09, 2012 in Rikuzentakata, Japan. People see the tree\'s miraculous survival as a symbol of hope and want to preserve it as a living monument. As the one year anniversary approaches, the areas most affected by an earthquake and subsequent tsunami that left 15,848 dead and 3,305 missing according to Japan\'s National Police Agency, continue to struggle. Thousands of people still remain without homes and are living in temporary dwellings. The Japanese government faces an uphill battle with the need to dispose of rubble as it works to rebuild economies and livelihoods. (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Japan Prepares To Mark 1 Year Anniversary Of Earthquake And Tsunami(16 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 09: A single pine tree is left standing after last year\'s March 11th tsunami, which swept away an entire forest in the city of Rikuzentakata, is seen on March 09, 2012 in Rikuzentakata, Japan. People see the tree\'s miraculous survival as a symbol of hope and want to preserve it as a living monument. As the one year anniversary approaches, the areas most affected by an earthquake and subsequent tsunami that left 15,848 dead and 3,305 missing according to Japan\'s National Police Agency, continue to struggle. Thousands of people still remain without homes and are living in temporary dwellings. The Japanese government faces an uphill battle with the need to dispose of rubble as it works to rebuild economies and livelihoods. (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Japan Prepares To Mark One Year Anniversary Of Earthquake And Tsunami(17 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 07: A single pine tree that was left standing after the March 11th tsunami, which swept away an entire forest in the city of Rikuzentakata, is seen on March 07, 2012 in Rikuzentakata, Japan. People see the tree\'s miraculous survival as a symbol of hope and want to preserve it as a living monument. As the one year anniversary approaches, the areas most affected by an earthquake and subsequent tsunami, that left 15,848 dead and 3,305 missing according to Japan\'s National Police Agency, continue to struggle. Thousands of people still remain without homes living in temporary dwellings. The Japanese government faces an uphill battle with the need to dispose of rubble as it works to rebuild economies and livelihoods. (Photo by Daniel Berehulak/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Japan Prepares To Mark 1 Year Anniversary Of Earthquake And Tsunami(18 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 10: A single pine tree that was left standing after the March 11th tsunami last year, which swept away an entire forest in the city of Rikuzentakata, is seen on March 10, 2012 in Rikuzentakata, Japan. On the eve of the one year anniversary of the Tohoku earthquake and tsunami the effected areas have been inundated with families, friends and relatives, the limited amount of hotels in the area are full to capacity with the worlds media and people from across Japan are arriving to take part in ceremonies paying tribute to the many people who lost their lives. The 9.0 magnitude strong earthquake struck offshore on March 11, 2011 at 2:46pm local time, triggering a tsunami wave of up to ten metres which engulfed large parts of north-eastern Japan and also damaged the Fukushima nuclear plant, causing the worst nuclear crisis in decades. The number of dead and missing ammounted to over 25,000 people. (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Japan Prepares To Mark 1 Year Anniversary Of Earthquake And Tsunami(19 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 10: A single pine tree that was left standing after the March 11th tsunami last year, which swept away an entire forest in the city of Rikuzentakata, is seen on March 10, 2012 in Rikuzentakata, Japan. On the eve of the one year anniversary of the Tohoku earthquake and tsunami the effected areas have been inundated with families, friends and relatives, the limited amount of hotels in the area are full to capacity with the worlds media and people from across Japan are arriving to take part in ceremonies paying tribute to the many people who lost their lives. The 9.0 magnitude strong earthquake struck offshore on March 11, 2011 at 2:46pm local time, triggering a tsunami wave of up to ten metres which engulfed large parts of north-eastern Japan and also damaged the Fukushima nuclear plant, causing the worst nuclear crisis in decades. The number of dead and missing ammounted to over 25,000 people. (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Japan Commemorates First Anniversary Of Earthquake And Tsunami(20 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 11: A man looks at a single pine tree left standing after the March 11, 2011 tsunami swept away an entire forest, on March 11, 2012 in Rikuzentakata, Japan. People see the tree\'s miraculous survival as a symbol of hope and want to preserve it as a living monument. Today marks the one year anniversary of the 9.0 magnitude earthquake and tsunami that occured on March 11, 2011 and engulfed large parts of northeastern Japan. The number of dead and missing amounted to over 15,000 people. (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Japan Commemorates First Anniversary Of Earthquake And Tsunami(21 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 11: A single pine tree left standing after the March 11th tsunami, which swept away an entire forest in the city of Rikuzentakata is seen reflected in muddy water on March 11, 2012 in Rikuzentakata, Japan. People see the tree\'s miraculous survival as a symbol of hope and want to preserve it as a living monument. On the one year anniversary, the areas most affected by last year\'s March 11, 2011 earthquake and subsequent tsunami that left 15,848 dead and 3,305 missing according to Japan\'s National Police Agency, continue to struggle. Thousands of people still remain without homes living in temporary dwellings. The Japanese government faces an uphill battle with the need to dispose of rubble as it works to rebuild economies and livelihoods. Across the country people are taking part in ceremonies to pay respects to the people who lost their lives. (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Japan Commemorates First Anniversary Of Earthquake And Tsunami(22 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 11: A group of volunteers from Tokyo take photographs of the single pine tree left standing after the March 11th tsunami, which swept away an entire forest in the city of Rikuzentakata on March 11, 2012 in Rikuzentakata, Japan. The tree\'s miraculous survival is seen by the community as a symbol of hope and want to preserve it as a living monument. On the one year anniversary, the areas most affected by last year\'s March 11, 2011 earthquake and subsequent tsunami that left 15,848 dead and 3,305 missing according to Japan\'s National Police Agency, continue to struggle. Thousands of people still remain without homes living in temporary dwellings. The Japanese government faces an uphill battle with the need to dispose of rubble as it works to rebuild economies and livelihoods. Across the country people are taking part in ceremonies to pay respects to the people who lost their lives. (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Japan Commemorates First Anniversary Of Earthquake And Tsunami(23 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 11: A man takes a picture of the single pine tree left standing after last year\'s March 11th tsunami, which swept away an entire forest in the city of Rikuzentakata on March 11, 2012 in Rikuzentakata, Japan. People see the tree\'s miraculous survival as a symbol of hope and want to preserve it as a living monument. On the one year anniversary, the areas most affected by last year\'s March 11, 2011 earthquake and subsequent tsunami that left 15,848 dead and 3,305 missing according to Japan\'s National Police Agency, continue to struggle. Thousands of people still remain without homes living in temporary dwellings. The Japanese government faces an uphill battle with the need to dispose of rubble as it works to rebuild economies and livelihoods. Across the country people are taking part in ceremonies to pay respects to the people who lost their lives. (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)
Japan Commemorates First Anniversary Of Earthquake And Tsunami(24 of24)
RIKUZENTAKATA, JAPAN - MARCH 11: A single pine tree is left standing after last year\'s March 11th tsunami, which swept away an entire forest in the city of Rikuzentakata is seen at sunset on March 11, 2012 in Rikuzentakata, Japan. People see the tree\'s miraculous survival as a symbol of hope and want to preserve it as a living monument. On the one year anniversary, the areas most affected by last year\'s March 11, 2011 earthquake and subsequent tsunami that left 15,848 dead and 3,305 missing according to Japan\'s National Police Agency, continue to struggle. Thousands of people still remain without homes living in temporary dwellings. The Japanese government faces an uphill battle with the need to dispose of rubble as it works to rebuild economies and livelihoods. Across the country people are taking part in ceremonies to pay respects to the people who lost their lives. (Photo by Chris McGrath/Getty Images) (credit:Getty Images)